Saturday, July 20, 2024

How We Take a look at and Assessment Tents


We love to check and assessment gear.

You’ll discover us testing gear that we already personal and love, are buying for retail costs (similar to you), or gadgets which might be despatched to us by the producer.

Unbiased Tent Critiques

Testing and Reviewing Tents
We totally take a look at every tent, inspecting every little thing from the peak to the supplies used, to its climate resistance, and extra!

Our objective is to stay as unbiased as doable.

Irrespective of how we procure a product, our objective is to totally take a look at and assessment every merchandise and fee it in opposition to its friends.

We take tedious notes and examine even the tiniest of particulars.

Every thing goes right into a spreadsheet for evaluation from the size of the product to value comparisons, person rankings, and so forth.

Our Assessment & Score Course of

We Do What You Do We Go Camping
Establishing a White Duck canvas tent at a campground in Arizona

After hours of testing, reviewing, and analyzing every tent, we grade every tent on the next metrics a 1 to 10 scale:

  • Area & Consolation
  • High quality & Sturdiness
  • Worth
  • Climate Resistance
  • Ease of Use
  • Intangibles (distinctive options and key promoting factors)
  • Person Critiques

Relying upon what every purchaser is in search of in a tent, they’ll need to pay roughly consideration to every particular criterion.

Total Rating

Tent Product Ratings & Review System
Our grasp database of tents that we’ve examined and reviewed

The entire above metrics are factored into our scoring algorithm to create an Total Rating.

The Total Rating goes to be the very best for tents which might be top-notch in each class accordingly.

Subsequently solely a tent that gives nice all-around worth, climate resistance, high-quality supplies, together with intangibles AND nice person evaluations will rating higher than a tent that’s maybe particularly made for 4-seasons however can be extraordinarily costly.

  • High-scoring tents are available in with 8.0 or increased rankings
  • Good tents usually rating within the 7.5-7.9 vary
  • Stable tents rating within the 7.0-7.4 vary
  • Dangerous tents rating beneath 7.0

Or maybe a purchaser is in search of an amazing tent at an amazing worth? On this case, their tent might not be rated the very best, as a result of it might not be utilizing the very best of the very best supplies, however it can certainly have the very best value-to-price ratio.

So whereas the Total Rating is vital, it isn’t every little thing.

Area & Consolation

White Duck Prota Deluxe Has Enough Space for 4-6 people
This White Duck Prota Deluxe Has Sufficient Area for 4-6 individuals inside. We had greater than sufficient room for 4 individuals AND gear

From household tenting to romantic {couples} tenting, it is a big figuring out issue as as to whether the tent goes to reside as much as your expectations.

You don’t need to get this one incorrect…however in case you are a backpacker, you’ll not care as a lot for house and luxury, as you’ll for high quality/sturdiness and most of all weight.

We fee house and luxury for every tent inside their tent class and measurement. So for a 4-person tent, it’s rated compared with different 4-person tents. However this doesn’t imply {that a} 4-person tent will comfortably match 4 individuals. It merely gained’t. You’ll need a 6-person or 8-person tent to comfortably match 4 individuals.

After all, we additionally consider the general top. The excessive ceiling could make a smaller tent appear extra spacious than a low-profile tent with extensive dimensions.

In order you possibly can see, all of those metrics issue into the general Area and Consolation rating. 

High quality & Sturdiness

MSR Hubba Hubba 2 Person Backpacking Tent
This MSR Hubba Hubba is made with high-quality supplies from its Easton Syclone composite tent poles to its ultralight material

The primary think about figuring out the standard and sturdiness of the product is the supplies used.

Most tents use both nylon or polyester as their tent material, each of that are nice choices.

The distinction in high quality lies within the particulars, and never the precise selection of fabric.

When determining high quality, we take note of the seams, zippers, and general building of the tent.

One other vital issue is guarantee. While you’re shopping for a product coated with a guaranty, you possibly can relaxation assured you’re getting a defect-free product, otherwise you’re getting your a reimbursement.

We consider merchandise with a guaranty get bonus factors for high quality assurance.


CORE 6-Person Instant Tent
The CORE 6-person On the spot Tent is an incredible worth at solely $129 on Amazon (at time of publishing)

All tents aren’t created equally, and never all tents are priced equally both. Coleman for example produces an amazing price range tent, whereas Mountain Hardwear produces a tent that may face up to the weather. These tents is not going to be priced wherever shut to one another.

So we take each the worth of the tent together with the supplies, guarantee, producer and different key elements into assessing the worth of every tent.

You possibly can nonetheless have a tent with excessive worth even whether it is double the worth of one other. However once more, many elements play into this. Totally different tents include totally different value tags. However not each mannequin provides you a similar worth for the cash you pay.

Whether or not you’re shopping for a price range tent or in search of a premium choice, you possibly can see which one provides you the very best bang to your buck.

Climate Resistance

Dome tents like this Coleman, provide better water protection than other style-tents
Dome tents like this Coleman, present higher water safety than different style-tents

Does the tent let in water, or does it not? Does the tent face up to excessive winds, or collapse onto itself? Does the tent have good air flow through the summer time months or does it get too scorching and stuffy? 

Finally, it is a fairly easy metric to make use of for comparability. We consider a few traits:

  • Tent materials
  • Flooring materials
  • PU score
  • High quality of seams
  • Rain fly size

You also needs to remember that the larger the tent, the extra potential issues.

Ease Of Use

Ease of Use in Setting up And Taking Down A Tent
The Coleman Pop-Up Tent is Fast and Simple to Set-up AND take-down!

By ease of use, we primarily imply ease of set-up and take-down. Nobody likes spending an unnecessarily very long time pitching a tent.

To rank the tents on this class, we took into consideration what number of items they’ve, in addition to how lengthy it often takes a single camper to set the entire thing up.

You may discover that smaller tents usually rank increased on this class, which isn’t any coincidence.

Irrespective of how few steps it takes to pitch a particular tent, its general measurement performs an enormous function in how simple it’s for a single particular person to do this.


Tremendous Ventilation
The REI Wonderland Tent has great air flow with inverted V-shaped home windows and an enormous mesh cover

We are able to’t overlook in regards to the distinctive options of various fashions. 

Sure fashions have loads of storage pockets inside. That’s nice for having all of your necessities neatly organized and shut at hand.

Many bigger tents have multiple door, which makes it simpler to get out and in of the tent when sharing it with different campers.

What options would you like in a tent? Does the tent have two doorways? Maybe the tent has a big vestibule for storing tools? Is the tent is a two-room tent with a particular house for the kiddos or a canine? Possibly the footprint is included within the value?

This ALL will get factored into the intangibles rating.

Person Scores

Lastly, we are able to’t overlook about different individuals’s experiences with these tents.

Whereas sure fashions might need labored in our case, there’s a superb likelihood somebody on the market didn’t have the identical impression of the tent that we did.

We learn each assessment – the great, the unhealthy, and the ugly. Then, we examine them to determine the final opinion on a particular mannequin.

What we analyze depends upon the product, however we fee and assessment each product that we have a look at.

Editorial Course of

We then minimize via all of the noise and slim down our decisions to just some that might be a wonderful match for our viewers.

That is the place we ship probably the most worth since doing this by yourself would take numerous free time and occasional.

After that, we begin writing.

Utilizing mountains of knowledge we’ve collected, we undergo a number of rounds of modifying and revisions. That is to ensure we solely point out probably the most related info.

To summarize: we do what you’d do when you had been shopping for tenting or mountain climbing gear. We simply spend A LOT extra time on every assessment than the typical buyer.

In a means, you possibly can see us as your analysis service – we analysis and take a look at outside gear for you and ship solely probably the most related leads to an easy-to-read format.


Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles